The results of the most recent poll are a bit surprising to me, and got me wondering how the results would change if I altered the question a bit; Rank these 5 pitchers in order of effectiveness over the remainder of their major league career (Most effective first, least effective last).
The pitchers (listed alphabetically)
Is there a player who is a sure bust there? Is there a clear #1? Is there a surprise in store from Broadway or Egbert, or to a lesser extent, Floyd? Rank the pitchers and give a little insight into your reasoning in the comments. (I'll chime in with my own thoughts at some point.)