clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Thomas vs. Thome

New, 7 comments

Spurred on by some comments to this post, I was wondering who you guys thought was more likely to be more productive next season; Thomas or Thome?

I chose my words carefully. "Productive" can mean whatever you want it to mean. 1-for-1 with a HR and 4RBI's is productive, but not so much in the context of a full season.

Poll below the fold. -- Chime in with how what you feel each guy will produce next season. I'm not going to do community projection like we did for Iguchi, but I'm interested in seeing the range of opinions on the two.

As for the Iguchi projection, with all the excitement from the Winter Meetings, I forgot to mention it again. -- Here's the link -- I'll keep it open to projections until Friday. We should do a few more for the younger guys in the coming weeks too. (I'll be very interesting in the Brandon McCarthy projections)


Here's a slightly improved version of the table from comments in the other post.
Thomas Thome PA OPS+ WARP PA OPS+ WARP 30 712 125 6.7 644 169 8.0 31 590 129 5.3 613 191 10.3 32 707 160 9.7 698 151 7.8 33 79 95 .3 618 148 6.0 34 628 117 4.6 242 83 1.0 35 662 149 7.0 --- --- --- 36 311 151 3.8 --- --- --- 37 124 131 1.1 --- --- ---

Poll

Who will be more productive in '06?

This poll is closed

  • 17%
    Frank Thomas
    (5 votes)
  • 82%
    Jim Thome
    (23 votes)
28 votes total Vote Now