clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Terrerobytes: Royals build up Jason Vargas signing

Plus: MLBPA head dies, Jerry Reinsdorf prefers Bud Selig's style over David Stern's, and other baseball news

Lisa Blumenfeld

On Thursday afternoon, the Kansas City Royals announced that they would have a major announcement to make.

They were due for one, since three other AL Central teams had made a noteworthy addition already this offseason. The White Sox signed Jose Abreu, the Indians added David Murphy, and the Tigers upped the ante with the Prince Fielder-Ian Kinsler swap.

Now it was the Royals' turn, and they built up the anticipation.

Bob Dutton was correct, and this was the haul.

Yes, the Royals signed Jason Vargas for four years and $32 million. He found his stride in the Mariners organization and has built up a decent career out in the AL West with Seattle and Los Angeles as a changeup-based lefty who can't break 90.

2009 26 SEA 3 6 4.91 23 14 91.2 98 16 24 54 87
2010 27 SEA 9 12 3.78 31 31 192.2 187 18 54 116 104
2011 28 SEA 10 13 4.25 32 32 201.0 205 22 59 131 88
2012 29 SEA 14 11 3.85 33 33 217.1 201 35 55 141 99
2013 30 LAA 9 8 4.02 24 24 150.0 162 17 46 109 94
AL (5 yrs) 45 50 4.07 143 134 852.2 853 108 238 551 95

He's been a sturdy rotation piece over this stretch, and so an $8 million salary isn't a stretch. The length of the contract is what caught everybody's attention, especially in the immediate reaction over at Royals Review. I think they would've been excited had Dayton Moore been able to land his Plan A, which was Tim Hudson. Vargas runs the threat of being another Jeremy Guthrie signing by comparison.

When you filter out the backlash from the buildup and the subsequent letdown, it might just be one of those year-too-long free agent contracts that are inevitable when the player has the leverage on the open market. Like Vargas' performance, the worst of the reactions from the analyst gallery aren't that bad, but there's no excitement, either.

From Rany Jazayerli:

A four-year deal requires upside to counterbalance the inherent downside. The Royals didn’t get any here. Vargas is what he is: a quiet, comfortable, league-average innings eater. He might look a little better than that in 2014, if the Royals’ defense comes through for him – but keep in mind that the quality of a team’s defense can change quickly, and there’s no guarantee the Royals will even have an above-average defense by the last half of this contract. But there’s essentially no chance that Vargas is going to get any Cy Young votes during his four years with the team. There’s a good chance that he’ll be worth what he’s paid, and a decent chance he’ll get hurt and be overpaid, but very little chance that he’ll be underpaid.

From Dave Cameron:

This can’t be the Royals big off-season move. Vargas fills a hole with the expectation of reasonable performance, but he doesn’t really make them better than they were, especially since he’s replacing Ervin Santana. They’re going to have to find other ways to upgrade if they want to become a contender. But this is also a decent enough contract for a decent enough pitcher to make sure that they don’t throw away their season by handing a rotation spot to a total scrub. Jason Vargas might not raise the Royals ceiling all that much, but he does raise their floor. And there’s value in that kind of transaction.

From Keith Law:

The Kansas City Royals were right to target an affordable starting pitcher this winter, but giving Jason Vargas, a fifth starter who might be a No. 4 in the right situation, a four-year deal shows way too much faith in his ability to adapt and survive as a finesse guy -- even though the annual salary ($8 million) isn't that high.

From some jerk:



MLBPA executive director Michael Weiner died at the age of 51 on Thursday, losing a prolonged battle with brain cancer. He had only been on the job for a couple years before he and the union needed to start working on a succession plan, but it looks like he'll have established a strong legacy in a too-brief time, considering the interests he had to balance. In the end, he held up his end of labor peace and maintained the support of the players while working with Major League Baseball to strengthen the drug-testing program -- and making it look easy. Ken Rosenthal and Jerry Crasnick each wrote fine tributes.

Jeff Zimmermann calls 2013 "a banner season for players going on the disabled list," and the White Sox helped with a worse-than-usual year for them.

On the flipside of company-labor relations, Jerry Reinsdorf heaps plenty of praise on Bud Selig, whom he calls "the best commissioner we in baseball have ever had." It gets more interesting when he compares Selig with David Stern -- although he likes operating under Selig more, since Selig asks for more input from the owners.

Mike Berardino of the St. Paul Pioneer-Press says the Twins are looking into Gavin Floyd, but their top target remains Bronson Arroyo. Signing Arroyo seems like a very Twins-like thing to do.

So Peter Gammons compared Alex Rodriguez to the Tsarnaev brothers, which seems very unlike Gammons. His subsequent apologies were very like Gammons, so he's close to back to Square One. Still, A-Rod's bizarre behavior tends to evoke similar bizarre behavior, which makes me glad that he's not our news story.