clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Congratulations to the Hall of Fame Class of 2021: [sad trombone]

New, 24 comments

No one makes the cut — and no player comes particularly close

Rows of empty folding chairs at Porter County Fair. Jeffrey Greenberg/Universal Images Group via Getty Images

Well, just because it was anticipated doesn’t make it any fun.

For the first time in the 11 years of the South Side Sox Hall of Fame voting, we have elected zero candidates from our regular Cooperstown ballot. The fewest prior inductees was way back in 2012, when Barry Larkin was enshrined all by his lonesome.

SSS voters averaged 8.28 choices per ballot (up from 8.04 last year at South Side Hit Pen); with still well more than 10 worthy players, a healthy list is a wise direction to take with your HOF ballots.

Here are the full results from this year’s voting, with the voting trend from 2019 to 2020 when applicable.

Get your speeches ready

None

Strong support

Todd Helton (58.2%, +21%)
Andruw Jones (52.8%, +8%)
Barry Bonds (55.5%, +2%)
Mark Buehrle (54.5%, first year)
Manny Ramirez (54.5%, +17%)

You got some work to do

Scott Rolen (49.1%, +18%)
Roger Clemens (47.3%, -5%)
Gary Sheffield (42.1%, -2%)
Curt Schilling (38.2%, -20%)
Jeff Kent (36.4%, +11%)
Paul Konerko (34.5%, -2%)
Bobby Abreu (31.8%, +11%)
Sammy Sosa (31.8%, +11%)
Trevor Hoffman (30.9%, -15%)

At least they got double digits

Andy Pettitte (30%, +13%)
Tim Hudson (27.3%, first year)
Roy Oswalt (27.3%, +19%)
Lance Berkman (25.5%, +13%)
Johan Santana (25.5%, +16%)
Omar Vizquel (22.7%, -6%)
Billy Wagner (20.9%, -6%)
Torii Hunter (13.6%, first year)

Still on the ballot

Cliff Lee (5.5%, even)

Off the ballot

A.J. Burnett (0%)
Michael Cuddyer (0.9%)
Dan Haren (0.9%)
LaTroy Hawkins (0.9%)
Aramis Ramirez (0.9%)
Nick Swisher (0.9%)
Shane Victorino (0%)
Barry Zito (1.8%)

Mark Buehrle had an extraordinary debut in the voting, and who knows, might see proper induction from SSS in his active ballot time. There were other inspiring leaps from some players already on the ballot, including Todd Helton (+21%), Manny Ramirez (a somewhat puzzling +17%) and Scott Rolen (+18%).

Meanwhile, Barry Bonds (+2%), Roger Clemens (-5%) and Curt Schilling (-20%) face huge obstacles for their final year (2022) on the ballot. Other big drops came from Trevor Hoffman (-15%), Omar Vizquel (-6%) and Billy Wagner (-6%).

Next year will also be complicated by the addition of two strong (but not uncontroversial) candidates: Alex Rodriguez and David Ortíz. And two old White Sox friends, A.J. Pierzynski and Jake Peavy, will be eligible for the first time.

Thanks to all who voted, and stay tuned early next week for our final phase of Hall of Fame voting, the most fun one of all: the fourth annual White Sox Hall of Fame!


South Side Sox 2011 Hall of Fame Class
Roberto Alomar
Bert Blyleven
Tim Raines

South Side Sox 2012 Hall of Fame Class
Barry Larkin

South Side Sox 2013 Hall of Fame Class
Craig Biggio
Mike Piazza
Tim Raines

South Side Sox 2014 Hall of Fame Class
Greg Maddux
Frank Thomas
Tom Glavine

South Side Sox 2015 Hall of Fame Class
Randy Johnson
Pedro Martinez
Craig Biggio
John Smoltz

South Side Sox 2016 Hall of Fame Class
Ken Griffey, Jr.
Tim Raines
Mike Piazza

South Side Sox 2017 Hall of Fame Class
Tim Raines
Vladimir Guerrero
Jeff Bagwell
Ivan Rodriguez

South Side Sox 2018 Hall of Fame Class
Jim Thome
Chipper Jones
Vladimir Guerrero

South Side Sox 2019 Hall of Fame Class
Mariano Rivera
Mike Mussina
Roy Halladay
Edgar Martinez

South Side Hit Pen 2020 Hall of Fame Class
Derek Jeter
Larry Walker

South Side Sox 2021 Hall of Fame Class
Null

(and no, I don’t know why the prior administration kept electing and re-electing Tim Raines to the HOF, although the voters were right each time)